Rigatoni all’ Amatriciana (Pasta Amatriciana)


This post is long over-due…I made Amatriciana for my family about a month ago and the photos had been sitting on my computer since then. It was only after I watched an episode of Australian Masterchef, during which one of the contestants had to replicate Cesare Casella’s Amatriciana, that I felt urged to stand up for the authenticity of this traditional Italian pasta dish. Even the lovely and talented Lidia Bastianich, who served as a guest judge on the show, could not refrain her..ehm..surpirse, when she tasted an array of extraneous ingredients in the sauce. It was undoubtably tasty, but Amatriciana it was not. This is one of those dishes that causes animated and feisty conversations at an Italian dinner table. Does it have onion? Is it made with pancetta or guanciale? Is the tomato supposed to be there? It doesn’t really concern me who’s wrong or right, what tastes better or worse. All I care about, in my quest for the authenticity of this dish, now part of Lazio Prodotto Agroalimentare Tradizionaleis to preserve its culinary heritage. Amatriciana is told to be the direct offspring of Pasta alla Gricia, which used to be made with guanciale (pork cheek) and pecorino only and to this day it is still a popular dish, in its simplicity, in Central Italy. Sometime in the 18th century, some innovative cook from Amatrice, must have decided tomatoes would be a valuable addition to the Gricia recipe, turning this peasant meal into one of Italy’s most loved exports. Even the choice of pasta is dictated by tradition. Originally it was Spaghetti, but these days Bucatini and Rigatoni are well tolerated. A friend of mine from Amatrice, Massimo , will tell you that any other pasta such as penne or tagliatelle is not simply to avoid, it is to be forbidden!


200 gr (1/3 cup) of chopped guanciale (cured pork cheek)

extra virgin olive oil

chopped dry chillie

a tablespoon of white wine vinegar

1/4 cup of dry white wine

450 gr (1 lb) of pasta

500 gr (2 cups) of peeled tomatoes (tinned tomatoes) or passata

Salt and pepper to taste

Freshly grated Pecorino cheese to serve


1. Fry the guanciale or pancetta in EVOO . Keep the flame low to allow the fat to render and the pork to develop a sweet flavour. When it’s starting to get a nice sun-burnt colour, add a sprinkle of chopped dry chillie and glaze the pan withwhite wine vinegar and  dry white wine. The acidity will balance the richness of the caramelized cured pork.

2. In the meantime, drop 450 gr (1 lb) of pasta into salted boiling water.

3. Return to your sauce. When the alcohol has evaporated, add the tinned tomatoes (or passata) and allow to cook for 20-25 minutes over low heat. Taste for salt and adjust accordingly.

4. When the pasta is al dente, drop it into your sauce, with a couple of tablespoons of acqua di cottura (pasta cooking water). This will help to bind the sauce and achieve a creamy consistency. Turn the heat off and mix through a very generous amount of pecorino and freshly ground black pepper, if liked . Let it rest for a few minutes before serving, to allow the pepperiness of the cheese to impregnate the pasta.


Open a bottle of Montepulciano D’Abruzzo, and you are already in Italy.

Silvia’s Cucina is on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest

18 Comments Add yours

  1. Jane Thomas says:

    Sounds absolutely delicious – but where would I find guanciale? Jane

    1. Hi Jane,
      are you in Australia? I live in Sydney and find all kinds of Italian things in a few places. If you are here too, I’ll tell you where to go. Cheers

      1. Jane Thomas says:

        Yes I am in Sydney – in Darlinghurst.
        Thanks, Jane.

  2. Hi Jane! Well, than you ought to go to Five docks and check out PETER’S DELI
    Great North Road, Five Dock, NSW. You can harldy hear any English spoken in there!

    1. Jane Thomas says:

      Thank you. I’m looking forward to trying the recipe.

  3. Paolo Cammeresi says:

    Bene finalmente sono daccordo con qualcuno sia sulla ricetta all”amatriciana ( io veramente metto anche la cipolla ) che sull’esito di quella puntata di masterchef sono rimasto allibito nel vedere quel muccchio di roba cucinato insieme. Ma ti prego dammi un suggerimento dove trovare il guanciale in Australia; sono 3 anni e mezzo che vivo a Perth e credo di aver chiesto ovunque senza aver avuto una risposta decente se non delle guance di maiale fresche di macello che non ho potuto usare.
    Adesso provero’ con la tua traduzione ( temo che mi e’ sempre mancato il ” cured ” )
    ma se hai qualche nominativo da queste parti fammi sapere. Complimenti per il sito seguiro’ altri tuoi suggerimenti. Ciao Paolo

    1. Paolo, io sono a Sydney, non sono sicura di dove tu possa trovare il guanciale a Perth… Mi informo..

    2. alessandro cucculelli says:

      Scusate l’intrusione,vi faccio i complimenti per il blog essendo appassionato di cucina fa piacere che connazionali dall’altra parte del mondo si confrontino sul nostro buon cibo,anche se la cipolla,specialmente se rossa, nell’amatriciana dona quel tocco di dolcezza al piatto.
      Vengo al nocciolo del mio intervento,ho necessità di avere un contatto diretto con te Paolo Cammeresi se sei lo stesso Paolo Cammeresi ha abitato ad Ostia Lido,ti lascio la mia mail ale.cuc@hotmail.it
      Un saluto a tutti!

      1. Ciao Ale, grazie per esserti fermato qui.

  4. Si, anche io la faccio in questo modo. Pero non ci metto l’aceto. Solamente il vino bianco. Silvia, il tuo blog e davvero meraviglioso e sono una tua nuova fan! Anna

    1. Ciao Anna! Grazie per le tue parole.
      In effetti anche io ero dubbiosa sull’ utilizzo dell’aceto, Ma dopo insistenti pressioni di un amico di Amatrice, ho provato e ora lo uso sempre, insieme al vino bianco. Trovo aiuti molto a bilanciare la ricchezza del guanciale.

  5. bellini says:

    Italians find it very important to stay true to a recipe, but even so there would be a different recipe from every cook. I had the same experience with Bolognese.

  6. As a former resident of the Eternal City, it’s one of my very favorite pasta dishes. I’m definitely in the “no onion” camp. Intrigued by the addition of vinegar—will have to try that next time.

    1. HI Frank!
      The vinegar simply offsets the greasiness of the guanciale. I often use white wine though…depending on what I have on hand!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s